Understanding the Environmental Footprint of Products: Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

What is LCA and Why is it Important?

Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) is a method aimed at evaluating the environmental impacts of products and processes throughout their life cycles. LCA analyzes all stages, from the extraction of raw materials to manufacturing, use, disposal, and all intermediate transportation stages. It involves compiling comprehensive inventories of energy, water, and material inputs, as well as waste and emissions at each stage, and calculating the potential environmental impacts of products. Unlike narrow environmental impact assessments, LCA's holistic approach aims to prevent environmental problems from being transferred from one stage of the product's life cycle to another. The current standard LCA method, defined by the Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC) in 1991, was initially standardized by ISO 14040:1997, ISO 14041:1999, ISO 14042:2000, and ISO 14043:2000. These standards were later updated by ISO 14040:2006 and ISO 14044:2006. Since its development, many impact assessment methods, software, and databases have been developed to support, improve, and make LCA more effective. These software tools will be discussed in the later parts of this article. Along with LCA, methods that evaluate the economic and social dimensions of product sustainability, such as Life Cycle Cost Analysis (LCCA) and Social Life Cycle Assessment (SLCA), also exist.

What are the Basic Stages of LCA?

The standard LCA method mentioned in ISO documents consists of four main stages: goal and scope definition, life cycle inventory analysis, life cycle impact assessment, and interpretation of results. The stages and information about them are presented below:

Goal and Scope Definition: This stage defines the purpose of the planned LCA study, its target audience, key variables, data requirements, constraints, and assumptions used. Two critical elements that define the scope and results of the study are system boundaries and functional units. When determining system boundaries, it is necessary to identify which stages and unit processes of the product's life cycle will be included in the analysis, which will be excluded, and the reasons for this. The functional unit represents the basic function of the examined system and should be specified clearly and in detail, reflecting the core function of the product or system. For example, for an LCA study comparing a cotton t-shirt and a polyester t-shirt, the functional unit could be defined as "one t-shirt's one-year usage period." All inventory inputs and outputs and analysis results in the study are expressed through this functional unit.

Life Cycle Inventory Analysis: In this stage, energy, water, and raw material inputs, as well as solid waste, wastewater, and air emissions within the boundaries of the analyzed system, are identified. Inventory information for all unit processes in the product's life cycle is collected and calculated using data collection forms, and missing data is completed through literature reviews and sectoral reports. All collected data is reorganized according to the functional unit, making it ready for calculating environmental impacts. The quality and accuracy of the collected data are crucial for this stage, and therefore it should be frequently reviewed.

Life Cycle Impact Assessment: In this stage, potential environmental impacts are calculated using the inventory data collected in the previous stage. This stage includes four sub-stages defined as mandatory (classification and characterization) and optional (normalization and weighting) by ISO 14040:2006.

Classification: In this sub-stage, inventory items are assigned to relevant environmental impact categories. For example, CO2 emissions are included in the "Global Warming" category. Other examples of environmental impact categories include acidification, eutrophication, ozone depletion, ecotoxicity, carcinogenic effects, and resource consumption.
Characterization: In the characterization sub-stage, the total impact for each environmental impact category is calculated using inventory items contributing to the same environmental issue. For example, calculating the global warming potential using CO2, CH4, and N2O emissions expressed in kg CO2 equivalents is an example of this sub-stage.
Normalization: In this sub-stage, different environmental impact potentials are made dimensionless and comparable by converting them to a common reference system using various normalization methods. This allows determining which environmental impact potential is higher.
Weighting: In this sub-stage, normalization results are multiplied by weighting factors using weighting methods, revealing which environmental impact potential is more significant. Impact analysis results can be calculated using relevant indicators with a midpoint or endpoint approach according to the study's objectives.

Interpretation of Results: The purpose of this stage is to evaluate the results of both the inventory and environmental impact analysis stages in line with the study's goals and scope, revealing important findings related to the examined system or product and making recommendations. In this stage, the scope of the study can be reviewed and adjusted if necessary, based on the obtained results.

These four stages of the LCA methodology interact with each other, allowing necessary corrections to be made in other stages based on the results obtained in each stage.

LCA's Impact on Decision-Making Processes

LCA is a critical tool for evaluating the environmental impacts of products and achieving sustainability goals. Therefore, correctly interpreting LCA results plays a significant role in improving environmental performance and making strategic decisions. This section provides examples of how LCA results are interpreted and impact decision-making processes in various fields.

Product Design and Development: LCA is frequently used in product design and development. For example, an LCA study on developing a more sustainable automobile component evaluated producing a plastic part in the car's dashboard with different composite materials such as aluminum and steel. The results showed:

The carbon footprint was identified as the most critical impact category.
Transitioning to bio-composite materials reduced the environmental footprint in five different categories, including climate change and primary energy demand.
The environmental impacts caused by aluminum usage could only be avoided by using steel.

Using these results, it may be reconsidered to use materials with lower environmental impacts instead of plastic in the car's dashboard.

Supply Chain Management: LCA is also effectively used in supply chain management. For example, a food producer aiming to reduce the carbon footprint of its products found that most greenhouse gas emissions occurred at the agricultural stage through LCA applications. This finding led the company to collaborate with suppliers adopting sustainable agricultural practices and increase local resource usage. These strategic changes reduced the overall environmental impact of the products.

Material Selection: LCA is used in material selection processes as well. For example, a construction company used LCA to choose the most suitable materials for a new building project. The application revealed that concrete production led to high energy consumption and CO2 emissions. This information prompted the company to decide to use alternative materials with lower environmental impacts, such as recycled steel or wood.

Policy and Regulation Development: LCA is also a significant tool in policy and regulation development. For example, a government used LCA results to develop policies to reduce the environmental impacts of single-use plastic products. The analysis showed that the environmental impact of plastic bags was high. This finding led to policies such as the recent implementation in our country, where single-use plastic bags are sold to encourage more sustainable alternatives.

End-of-Life Management of Products: LCA can also be used as a decision-making mechanism in end-of-life management processes of products. For example, an electronics manufacturer aiming to minimize the environmental impacts at the end of the product's life cycle found through LCA applications that recycling electronic waste consumed less energy and created less pollution compared to extracting raw materials. This information led the company to start product take-back and recycling programs. These programs reduced environmental impacts while also increasing customer satisfaction.

In summary, correctly interpreting LCA results is crucial for identifying and improving environmental impacts. The examples above show how LCA can be used in different processes such as product design, supply chain management, material selection, policy development, and end-of-life management of products. These analyses' results can guide achieving sustainability goals and making more environmentally friendly decisions.

LCA and Sectoral Applications

As mentioned in the previous heading, LCA is a critical decision-making tool in many different processes. Therefore, LCA studies can be found in many different sectors. Below are some of these sectors and information about LCA applications in these sectors:

Wastewater Treatment Sector: LCA in Sludge Disposal Scenarios In the wastewater sector, an LCA study was conducted on sludge disposal methods. This study evaluated the resource consumption and pollutant emissions of different sludge disposal scenarios. One ton of dry sludge was determined as the functional unit. Five different sludge disposal scenarios were examined: sludge incineration and landfill, lime stabilization and landfill, lime stabilization and land application, composting and land application, anaerobic digestion and land application. In the sludge incineration and landfill method, pollutants such as CO2, NOx, SOx released during incineration, the energy-intensive process of incineration, and the disposal of ash after incineration can create environmental impacts. Lime stabilization and landfill process create a carbon footprint due to lime production and use, and stabilized sludge's disposal can potentially contaminate groundwater and soils. In the lime stabilization and land application scenario, while stabilized sludge application can increase soil fertility, it also has the potential to contaminate groundwater and soils if burned. Again, lime use creates a carbon footprint. In the composting and land application method, composting allows organic matter to decompose naturally, turning sludge into beneficial compost. When applied to land, it increases soil fertility. When done correctly, harmful gas emissions are minimized. Finally, in the anaerobic digestion and land application method, anaerobic digestion produces biogas (methane), which can be used as an energy source, reducing reliance on fossil fuels. The remaining sludge after digestion can be used as fertilizer and increase soil fertility. When biogas is properly captured and used, greenhouse gas emissions are minimized. The results showed that the highest resource consumption occurred during the lime stabilization and land application process due to fossil fuels used in sludge transportation and lime used. The scenarios contributing the most to climate change were sludge incineration and landfill due to the gases released. The lowest environmental impact was observed in the anaerobic digestion and land application and composting and land application scenarios.

Construction Sector: LCA Study on Fly Ash Concrete An LCA study on fly ash concrete used in the construction sector was conducted in Turkey. This study evaluated the environmental performance of fly ash concrete mixtures. While 1 m³ concrete was determined as the functional unit, evaluations were made based on this functional unit's global warming potential (GWP). Concrete mixtures containing different proportions of fly ash were evaluated using LCA software. Using the software, environmental impacts were calculated in terms of CO2 equivalents. According to the results obtained from the evaluations, CO2 equivalent emissions were found to be 800.14 kg CO2 for 1m³ of concrete without fly ash, 608.16 kg CO2 for concrete containing 25% fly ash, and 460.96 kg CO2 for concrete containing 45% fly ash. Based on these results, concrete without fly ash was determined to have the highest global warming potential.

Food Sector: LCA Study on Different Fruit Juice Packaging An LCA study on different packaging scenarios was conducted in the food sector. This study focused on fruit juice packaging and compared the environmental impacts of glass fruit juice bottles with barrier-layer fruit juice bottles. The functional unit was selected as 1 liter of fruit juice packaging, and a cradle-to-grave approach was adopted. This means that the system boundary included raw material acquisition, production, transportation, use, and disposal. The results of the environmental impact assessment showed that glass bottles had more impact. The reason for this was that the transportation impacts, due to glass bottles being heavier than barrier-layer bottles, negatively affected the environmental performance of glass bottles. This weight led to higher fuel consumption during transportation and, therefore, higher CO2 emissions. Additionally, being more voluminous, fewer products could be transported, reducing transport efficiency.

These examples show how LCA can be applied in different sectors. As can be seen from the examples above, LCA applications help develop sustainable waste management strategies by minimizing environmental impacts and increasing resource efficiency in the wastewater treatment sector, while in the construction sector, LCA evaluations of material selection and construction processes contribute to developing greener buildings and sustainable construction methods. In the food sector, LCA helps reduce the environmental footprint of processes from production to consumption and adopt sustainable agriculture and food production methods.

LCA Software

LCA software uses various data and methodologies to evaluate the environmental impacts of products throughout their life cycle. Some common LCA software tools include SimaPro, Sphera, OpenLCA, Umberto, Ecochain, and Brightway. Information about these software tools is provided below:

SimaPro: One of the most widely used software for LCA studies. It stands out with comprehensive databases and a user-friendly interface. SimaPro offers a wide range of analyses for various sectors, allowing users to evaluate environmental impacts in detail.

Sphera (formerly GaBi): Sphera, formerly known as GaBi, is extensive LCA software for industrial and academic research. With comprehensive databases and flexible modeling capabilities, it helps users analyze complex systems. Sphera is preferred for large-scale projects and detailed environmental impact assessments.

OpenLCA: Open-source LCA software. This software allows users to create their own databases and integrate various analysis tools with its flexible and extensible structure. OpenLCA is suitable for both beginners and advanced users and is continuously developed by the community.

Umberto: LCA software that stands out with its user-friendly interface and robust modeling capabilities. Umberto, used for modeling energy flows, material flows, and environmental impacts, is widely used in sustainability projects and environmental management systems.

Ecochain: Offers two different LCA tools: Mobius and Helix. Mobius helps companies manage product life cycle analyses and environmental impacts, while Helix is developed for more detailed and comprehensive analyses. Ecochain tools help users improve environmental efficiency and achieve sustainability goals.

Brightway: Open-source LCA software written in the Python programming language. Brightway is a powerful tool for researchers and analysts with its flexible structure and extensive database. Users can easily create their own analyses and models and work with existing databases.

LCA software tools are essential tools for sustainability studies in various sectors, helping users analyze environmental impacts and make more informed and efficient decisions. Each software has its unique features and advantages, so it is essential to choose the most suitable one according to needs and projects.

LCA Use and Trends in Turkey

The use of LCA in Turkey has seen a significant increase in recent years. The main reasons for this increase include growing environmental awareness, stricter national regulations on environmental impact assessment, and the adoption of environmentally friendly production processes to remain competitive in export markets. Industrial organizations in Turkey, especially companies exporting to the European market, are adopting LCA studies to reduce the environmental impacts of their products. In the construction sector, green building certifications and sustainable construction practices encourage the widespread use of LCA. In the automotive sector, evaluating the environmental impacts of vehicles throughout their life cycle, optimizing production processes, and developing recycling processes use LCA. Similarly, in the chemical and food sectors, LCA methods are adopted to minimize the environmental impacts of production processes and achieve sustainability goals.

Advances in digitalization and data analytics enable more detailed and comprehensive LCA studies. Big data analytics and artificial intelligence allow LCA to be conducted more accurately and quickly, enabling more precise assessment of environmental impacts. Additionally, the development and harmonization of international standards increase the comparability of LCA results, playing a significant role in achieving global sustainability goals. These trends show that LCA will become an even more important tool in the future, both in Turkey and globally. Both the private sector and public institutions will continue to use LCA studies more intensively to achieve sustainability goals and minimize environmental impacts.

References: